Open Feud over Hidden Rug


By Richard Simon

WASHINGTON (Washington Post) — In a new twist to efforts to call attention to the Armenian Genocide, a group of lawmakers has accused the Obama administration of blocking a Smithsonian display of a rug woven by orphans of the mass killings nearly a century ago.

The lawmakers wrote to President Obama urging him to make the rug available for exhibition. It was presented to President Calvin Coolidge in 1925 and has been in storage. The bipartisan group includes more than a dozen representatives from California, which has a large Armenian American population.

The roughly 12-foot-by-18-foot Armenian Orphan Rug was to be featured in a Washington exhibit Dec. 16 at the Smithsonian Institution Building, known as the Castle, that sought to call attention to a new book about the rug, which the lawmakers called a “pivotal icon related to the Armenian Genocide.”

A White House spokeswoman said Tuesday that displaying the rug “for only half a day in connection with a private book launch event, as proposed, would have been an inappropriate use of US government property, would have required the White House to undertake the risk of transporting the rug for limited public exposure, and was not viewed as commensurate with the rug’s historical significance.

Aram S. Hamparian, executive director of the Armenian National Committee of America, attributed the decision to politics, contending that the administration was “catering to the Turkish government’s sensitivities about the Armenian genocide.”

Get the Mirror in your inbox:

“It is without a doubt a political decision,” he said in an interview. Hamparian was in New York on Tuesday to take up the issue with the US ambassador to Armenia, John A. Heffern.

An estimated 1.2 million Armenians were killed by Ottoman Turks as the empire was dissolving during World War I, an episode historians have concluded was genocide. But Turkey has contended that Turks and Armenians were casualties of war, famine and disease.

In September, a Smithsonian curator wrote the Armenian Cultural Foundation and Armenian Rugs Society, which were helping to organize the exhibit, that the White House decided that “it cannot lend” the rug for the exhibit. “Needless to say this was a great surprise and disappointment to us here,” wrote Paul Michael Taylor, director of the Smithsonian’s Asian cultural history program.

The rug, composed of more than 4 million hand-tied knots, was presented to Coolidge in appreciation for US humanitarian assistance. It features more than 100 images of animals, according to Hagop Martin Deranian, a 91-year-old Massachusetts dentist whose book “President Calvin Coolidge and the Armenian Orphan Rug” was to have been featured at the rug exhibit.

Rep. Adam B. Schiff (D-Burbank), who helped gather the signatures of 30 other lawmakers on a letter to the White House, called the White House decision “as inexplicable as it is hurtful to the Armenian community.” Schiff added, “The rug is not only a symbol of the resilience of the Armenian people through their darkest days; it also serves as a tangible expression of the inherent truth that not only were 1.5 million people killed in the first genocide of the 20th century, but that the American government was a central player in efforts to call attention to the plight of the Armenian people and provide relief to survivors.”

“It is difficult to express in words how deeply troubling it is that a historical and cultural treasure accepted by President Coolidge on behalf of the people of the United States may be being kept behind closed doors because of Turkish desire to keep discussion of certain historical facts out of the public discussion,” Rep. Frank Pallone Jr. (D-N.J.), co-chairman of the Congressional Caucus on Armenian Issues, wrote the White House in a separate letter. Rep. Brad Sherman (D-Sherman Oaks) also wrote the White House, urging that the rug be put on permanent display at the Smithsonian: “We must acknowledge and learn from the tragic crimes against humanity that orphaned the weavers of this rug to ensure that they are never repeated.”

Neither Schiff nor Sherman has received a White House response.

“The Armenian Orphan Rug is a piece of American history and it belongs to the American people. For over a decade, Armenian American organizations have sought the public display of the rug and have requested the White House and the State Department grant their request on numerous occasions. Unfortunately, Armenian Americans have yet to have their requests granted,” said Schiff.

Meanwhile, the Armenian Assembly of America, an organization promoting public understanding of Armenian issues supported the efforts by the congressmen. “The Assembly appreciates the efforts of the Armenian Caucus, and will continue to press the case to ensure that this historical treasure is appropriately and permanently displayed for all Americans to enjoy,” stated Assembly Executive Director Bryan Ardouny. “The Assembly also applauds the timely work of Dr. Hagop Martin Deranian and his new book documenting the history of this culturally significant rug and the support of the Armenian Cultural Foundation for ensuring its publication,” Ardouny added.

Established in 1972, the Armenian Assembly of America is the largest Washington-based nationwide organization promoting public understanding and awareness of Armenian issues. The Assembly is a non-partisan, 501(c)(3) tax-exempt membership organization.

The controversy over the rug, first reported by the Washington Post, is the latest development on an issue that has roiled Capitol Hill for years.

A House panel in 2010 passed a resolution to officially recognize the mass killings between 1915 and 1918 as genocide, but the measure never made it to the House floor for a vote after Turkey recalled its ambassador in protest and US officials warned it could damage US relations with Turkey, an important ally.

In 2007, after a majority of House members signed on as co-sponsors, the resolution appeared headed toward approval.

But two dozen lawmakers withdrew their support after the George W. Bush administration and the Turkish government warned that passage of the resolution could lead Turkey to block US access to its air bases used to get supplies to American troops in Iraq.

(The Mirror-Spectator staff contributed additional reporting to this article

Get the Mirror-Spectator Weekly in your inbox: