Dr. Vatche Minassian, left, and Dr. Samuel Badalian, in front of the Wigmore Women’s and Children’s Hospital in Yerevan (photo Aram Arkun)

Urogynecology Subspecialty Improves Lives for Women in Armenia

14
0

YEREVAN — Some six years ago, there was no medical subspeciality in female pelvic medicine and reconstructive surgery (FPMRS), also known as urogynecology, in Armenia. A simple inquiry led to the establishment of a fellowship program that led to the creation of this subspeciality and improved the lives of many Armenian women.

Dr. Samuel S. Badalian is the Chief of the Department of Women’s Health at Bassett Healthcare Network in New York, as well as a clinical professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at Columbia University Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons. Badalian had been coming for many years to Armenia to perform surgeries. Each time he said he would work on maybe 10-15 patients but realized that this approach was not sufficient and it would be better to create a program in Armenia.

Badalian decided that first research was needed to find out the prevalence of urogynecological disorders in Armenia. He came back from Armenia and called Dr. Vatche Minassian, whom he had known since 2005 from the American Urogynecological Society meetings. In 2010 Badalian had invited Minassian to come to Armenia and together they organized the first urogynecological conference there with many lectures.

Minassian is associate professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Harvard Medical School and a urogynecologist practicing in the Boston area. He served as chief of urogynecology at Brigham and Women’s Hospital until September 2025. (See accompanying article on the Armenian American Medical Association of Boston honoring Minassian in this issue.)

Minassian recalled that Badalian’s immediate spur to create a program was the interest expressed by a young Armenian OB-GYN. Realizing that nothing had been published on how often pelvic disorders occurred in Armenia, Minassian agreed that epidemiologic research was necessary to establish the prevalence of these conditions. Badalian suggested to Minassian that a study should include the Armenian provinces as well as the capital.

They designed a study and gave questionnaires which were filled by 540 patients. The data was sent to Dr. Elena Sagayan in San Francisco for analysis, and the final paper titled “The Prevalence of Pelvic Floor Disorders and Degree of Bother among Women Attending Primary Care Clinics in Armenia,” was published in the European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive Biology in 2020. The shocking discovery from the study was that the quality of life of women who had urogynecological surgery was actually worse than women who never had any surgery.

Get the Mirror in your inbox:

This meant that the surgeries at the time were being done without a true understanding of the anatomy or proper surgical techniques, and thus the Armenian Ministry of Health needed to support the creation of a urogynecological fellowship to teach Armenian physicians how to practice in this field.

Badalian said he sent a copy to Minister of Health Arsen Torosyan, who agreed with the idea, and sent an email to the dean of the Armenian National Institute of Health. When the process stalled, Badalian went back to Minassian and said that they need to create this fellowship themselves.

Starting the Fellowship Program

In order to create a formal fellowship program, they needed to identify suitable mentors. Minassian’s connections with many physicians in the US and the world, and Badalian’s own connections, led the duo to come up with mentors from different countries, including Raisa Platte, a residency program director at Cornwell Health, Michigan, Armen Kirakosyan, a urogynecologist from Buffalo, NY, Gevorg “George” Kasyan, a urologist from Moscow State Medico-Stomatological University, Russia, and urogynecologist Dr. Tony Bazi of the American University of Beirut, Lebanon. Together as volunteers they created the International Urogynecology Association for Armenia (IUGAA) in 2020. Assistant Professor Paul Hanissian from Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, NH, joined them virtually, and later John AlJamal from Tufts Urogynecology also helped.

The next step was how to select the fellows. That was challenging, Badalian said, because they needed to find young doctors who want to stay in Armenia. They reached out to a few hospitals in Armenia.

From left, Drs. Samuel Badalian, Anzhela Lekhlyan, Zaruhi Grigoryan and Vatche Minassian at Wigmore Women’s and Children’s Hospital in Yerevan (photo Aram Arkun)

Badalian and Minassian realized that it would not be possible to start the program while living in the United States, so Badalian applied for a Fulbright Scholarship to teach urogynecology in Armenia and spend six weeks there instead of one week at a time. During his first Fulbright visit, Badalian set up Zoom meetings with all the mentors to interview applicants for the fellowship program. Finally, they agreed to accept four OB-GYN physicians and one urologist in the program, who were working at three different Yerevan hospitals.

The program had to take place in the hospitals where the fellows were working and earning salaries, as the mentors had no way of providing salaries themselves. Badalian explained that they spoke with the hospital administrations to allow the fellows to follow the mentors when they were visiting in the various hospitals. The hospitals agreed because wherever they went, the mentors would do surgeries, which they did not know locally how to do.

With his Fulbright, Badalian said he was able in 2021-2022 to make three six-week visits and work hands on with the fellows, after which the other mentors could come for alternating one-week visits, sometimes twice a year, to see patients and operate with the five fellows.

The first six weeks were the toughest, Badalian recalled, because instead of surgery, he taught ethics and quality care, how to interact and speak with patients, and how to set up rooms. He said that the Soviet-style health facilities had no privacy or respect for patients, and people went to operating rooms even without changing their clothing. When Minassian came to visit after Badalian, he still was not happy with the physicians’ attitude, behavior and interaction with patients, though there was some improvement already.

However, as the program began during the COVID-19 pandemic, the teaching model was also hybrid one, with Zoom lectures, case presentations and journal clubs to discuss new publications and current standards. A WhatsApp group for daily case discussions was created.

During the first year, every week on Friday, the mentors gave lectures to the fellows and then there would be questions and answers. Every six months, a written exam with 60 questions was given to the fellows over 60 minutes.

During the second year, the fellows started giving talks, on topics assigned by the mentors, who became the audience. In the third year, the fellows gave case presentations and the mentors analyzed and questioned them. Then they had to do research projects. They were taken to the library, met with statisticians, and learned how to conduct research and analyze data.

The fellows gradually started to focus their clinical practice more on urogynecology care. Three urogynecology symposia were held in Armenia introducing the subspeciality and the fellows to the local medical community.

Wigmore Hospital

In 2023, the faculty established an agreement with the Wigmore Women’s and Children’s Hospital in Yerevan to create the first urogynecological center in Armenia. Wigmore was originally designed to only be a children’s hospital, but Badalian said they were able to convince them that children’s health without women’s health does not work, so obstetrics and urogynecology were added.

Wigmore existed for nine years, but the current clinic is only around three years old now, Badalian said. The building was built as a pediatric hospital with four floors being used.

Wigmore hired two of the fellows and gave privileges to perform surgeries to the other three. It purchased all the needed testing equipment as well as surgical equipment and instrumentation.

In negotiations with Wigmore, the investors and administrators were told that besides proper equipment, proper offices were needed equipped according to US standards. “Every single piece of equipment for exam rooms was ordered on our request: exam tables, lights, curtains, how doors are locked and how things are done,” Badalian said. They accepted all of it.

Dr. Zaruhi Grigoryan at one of the new rooms in the Urogynecology Service in Wigmore Women’s and Children’s Hospital in Yerevan (photo Aram Arkun)

Badalian declared, “The beauty of this place — why we chose to come here — was that they gave us an opportunity to create our own department. They gave us all the necessary equipment to establish it and move forward, which means autonomy.” He said the leadership in this hospital is progressive. Many other places work under an existing urology department, which makes it harder to implement changes.

Recognition and Next Steps

In 2024, the Avdalbekyan National Institute of Health of the Armenian Ministry of Health approved the pathway to obtain recognition of the field and in 2025 recognized urogynecology as a stand-alone subspeciality. The fellows in the program became the first urogynecologists of Armenia.

The fellowship training program received accreditation from the governing body of the International Urogynecology Association (IUGA). At first, Badalian said, the organization did not want to accept it but after multiple meetings and discussions it agreed and wrote a letter to the Minister of Health of Armenia to that effect.

All five fellows graduated in 2025 and presented their research in June of that year at the 50th International Urogynecology Association meeting in Barcelona, Spain. One fellow was recognized for the best video presentation. Badalian said, “This was the biggest day of celebration for us [mentors].”

Badalian said, “Now they have become our colleagues. They are not our fellows anymore.” On a television show in Armenia, when he was asked about it, he said, “You cannot imagine our satisfaction and happiness when you see those patients actually getting the help they need, and without us.” Minassian concurred.

A second group of fellows was then recruited from the Armenian provinces. While people living in the provinces near Yerevan can come to the city for treatment, there are financial and time-related issues for those in more distant areas. Therefore, two fellows were selected for the next stage of the fellowship who will be expected to work in the provinces after graduating.

Minassian noted that residency and fellowships in Armenia generally are tuition-based, unlike in the US where stipends are paid, but they made sure the urogynecology program was free of charge, as all mentors volunteered their services. In the second phase of the program, to prepare fellows to work in the provinces, the Armenian National Institute of Health will charge a nominal fee of nearly $200 per fellow.

The Friday noon education Zooms are still continuing, Badalian said, with both the mentors and the new colleagues in Armenia participating. Difficult cases are discussed there and in the WhatsApp group. Badalian said with great joy that at times the mentors themselves bring up their difficult cases and the former fellows provide their advice. Some of the latter now also review papers for the International Urogynecology Journal, for which one of the mentors, Dr. Tony Bazzi, is an editor.

In some ways the Armenian program even has advantages over fellowships in the US. Minassian said they have learned from six different mentors who physically came to Armenia, as well as a seventh who has been involved via Zoom and education, as well as an eighth. In the US, on average, urogynecology fellows usually learn techniques from three or four faculty.

Minassian noted that the program for Armenia became accepted as a hybrid model of fellowship training in developing countries or countries where such training is not available. He said that only 30 percent of the world at present has an official fellowship in this field.

Minassian said: “When we meet or talk with our international colleagues, many of them show interest and they’re in awe, wondering how did we do it? How can we learn from you? So we’re trying to strategize how can we export this knowledge and skills that we’ve developed to the outside world. This is an Armenian-based program that we’d like to export to other places. You need a lot of volunteer time and effort, and people on the ground who understand its importance and can provide the support to bring it forward.”

Badalian and Minassian published a paper in 2023 about this in the International Urogynecology Journal titled “Establishing Urogynecology Subspecialty in Armenia: The Armenia Project.” Several countries at present are interested in creating similar programs, Badalian and Minassian said.

An alternate approach would be, they noted, once at least 10 urogynecologists are trained and ready to work in Armenia, a program could be started there for doctors from other countries and Armenia would be an international center for training.

The First Graduates of the Fellowship

Dr. Zaruhi Grigoryan is the head of the Urogynecology Service at Wigmore Women’s and Children’s Hospital in Yerevan. A graduate of Yerevan State Medical University who completed a residency at Margaryan Hospital (formally called Research Center for Maternal and Child Health Protection), she was working in 2021 at the Armenian-American Wellness Center as a gynecologic surgeon when her colleagues told her about the urogynecology fellowship. Although she thought it would be very difficult because it is in English, she has a family and children, and her regular work lasts till 6 p.m., she said she very much wanted to be in the program because it is new, very interesting and there were no other such programs in Armenia. She said, “We always told everybody that this is the specialty that can change the destinies of people [i.e. patients], and of course our destinies too.”

The number of urogynecological patients at Wigmore has increased greatly. Grigoryan said that when she started the fellowship there were one or two patients weekly, but now, of the 20 patients she sees per day half are with urogynecological problems. Per month, half of the 30 surgeries conducted are also urogynecological cases. There are 15 beds in the department, eight of which are for obstetric patients and 7 for gynecology, but this will be increased because the department is growing. She said, “Now, everybody knows that for urinary incontinence or pelvic organ prolapse, they need to come to Wigmore Hospital – even ChatGPT knows about this.”

Dr. Anzhela Lekhlyan also works at Wigmore. A surgical gynecologist, she remarked there were two most important things the fellows learned from the program. First, they learned to interact with patients and respect them in a different manner than before. Secondly, they learned to try to avoid the risk of surgery and try to cure without it first. Surgery should be a last resort.

Lekhlyan added that before the fellowship, in Armenia it was accepted that after surgeries, you must stay from three to seven nights at the hospital. Often eating or walking was not allowed. However, they learned during the fellowship there were post-surgery guidelines so that the patient could leave the same day or the next day.

Dr. Gor Shadyan is the only fellow who first trained as a urologist. He learned about the fellowship from Prof. George Kasyan from whom he first learned urogynecology in 2015 at Moscow State Medical and Dental University. Dr. Hrachya Baghdasaryan, a surgeon at the Izmirlian Medical Center, where he works, was one of Badalian’s classmates and friends, suggested that the program accept him. Shadyan is a lecturer at YSMU in urology and andrology. He said he attempts to involve urologists from an urological perspective in urogynecology.

From left, Drs. Gor Shadyan, Lusine Sahakyan, Tigran Ter-Isahakyan at the GynArmenia International Conference in Gynecology 2026 in Yerevan (photo Aram Arkun)

Shadyan said, “What our mentors and this program have given us, and not only us, but to all Armenia, is indescribable. When I operate every day on women, I try to say that above us, our mentors follow what we are doing. … When we are operating, the great part of the work is done through our hands by our mentors.”

Dr. Tigran Ter-Isahakyan, a graduate of YSMU in obstetrics and gynecology, is now a urogynecologist, head of the Operative Gynecological Department at Beglarlyan Medical Center, and a lecturer at YSMU’s 1st Dept. of OB/GYN. He said one of the professors at Beglaryan told him he should definitely apply to the fellowship. He was accepted and observed that until then, his way of thinking was completely different. He said, “We did not imagine that when we are doing a gynecological operation, we must also absolutely think about urology – urinary incontinence. In other words, if you are a gynecologist, you deal more with organs like the womb and vagina, and you have to think about repair prolapse and urinary incontinence as needed. Once we started in 2021, during the course of the first one or one and a half months, our minds had categorically changed.”

He said that at Beglaryan, there was new equipment like at Wigmore but not a separate division for urogynecology. He said at least the idea is now there to open one.

Nevertheless, he said that along with the other four graduated fellows, he had agreed when being interviewed to transmit his knowledge later to younger people, completely without pay. As a lecturer in the medical university he teaches there what he has learned in the fellowship.

Dr. Tigran Ter-Isahakyan delivers his paper on enhanced recovery after surgery protocols at the GynArmenia International Conference in Gynecology 2026 in Yerevan (photo Aram Arkun)

He and the other fellows have learned to conduct research, make presentations, and try to publish their work. This year, Shadyan interjected, the fellows have published two papers and a third is in the course of finalization.

Ter-Isahakyan concluded, “I am very thankful to all our mentors. The most active were Professor Minassian and Professor Badalyan….Perhaps we have completed the fellowship program, but every time we meet, when we do joint operations, we learn something from them.”

Dr. Lusine Sahakyan, an obstetrician and gynecologist, who later learned urogyncecology, is a lecturer at YSMU and the youngest of the five original fellows. In 2021, she graduated her residency in obstetrics and gynecology. She said, “I thought I had finally finished learning and could start working, but barely 20 days had passed when Prof. Armine Harutyunyan, who was our clinical director, and who also played a role in the introduction of urogynecology to Armenia, told me to apply to study again. I became one of the fortunate five fellows – truly fortunate, because urogynecology was not given only to us as a specialty but was given to us as humans. We were changed as people and as doctors. As people, we became more compassionate.”

Dr. Lusine Sahakyan presenting her paper on conservative management of urinary incontinence at the GynArmenia International Conference in Gynecology 2026 in Yerevan (photo Aram Arkun)

She explained that they learned that the patient must not be seen as a source of income but as a person who has need of assistance, and you are obliged to help her without doing harm. She said that another important thing was that the fellows all learned how to work as a team and they continue to maintain this relationship.

Finally, she recalled, “Our professors — our mentors — have realized a huge effort for us and for Armenia, and it seems to me the love of our homeland unites us all. One of the preconditions for our starting the program was that none of us should desert Armenia. We must learn and then put what we learn to use in the service of the population of Armenia, for Armenian women and for Armenia.”

Sahakyan, like Ter-Isahakyan, conducts surgeries at Beglaryan, but she also goes to a medical center in Gyumri for consultations as much as her time permits, in order to make urogynecology accessible there.

At the entrance of the Matenadaran in Yerevan the banners appear for the GynArmenia International Conference in Gynecology 2026 in Yerevan, in which the five urogynecology fellows and several of their mentors spoke and helped organize (photo Aram Arkun)

Though Beglaryan and Wigmore are private hospitals, a way is found to treat all those who come their way, Sahakyan said. Urogynecological issues most frequently are found in older women, and the state has a plan for universal insurance for those over 65.

Why Volunteer?

A fellow in the second phase of the program told Minassian that his friends and colleagues are having a hard time understanding why Minassian and Badalian are volunteering their time, and without asking for compensation giving the fellows the knowledge and skills they need.

Minassian replied, “When you have children one day, you’re going to learn that when they are young, your children will want a phone, they will want a car, they will want sneakers — they’re looking for immediate gratification. So, I want, I want, I want. But the thing that brings happiness is when you give. That’s why we are here.”

Badalian commented that his wife calls the fellows his Armenian children. They may be only a little older than his biological children, but, he said, “The point is I consider them as my children. Like what I can give to my children, I give to them because they’re going to continue our work, and this is extremely important.”

This goes both ways. Badalian said, “We can see how much they love us, how much they care about us. I cannot even open my mouth and say, I need this. They come from all over. ‘I’ll take you this.’ ‘I’ll bring you this. I’ll give you this.’ There’s so much respect we can see from them. They do everything for us, whatever they think they can make our life a little bit better.”

More importantly, he said, “The whole idea of this is that they’re going to treat the next generation [of physicians] the same way.”

Get the Mirror-Spectator Weekly in your inbox: