Harut Sassounian at the ACEC (Kenneth Martin photo)

WATERTOWN — Publisher and syndicated columnist Harut Sassounian, delivering the keynote address at a community-wide commemoration of the 110th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide on Sunday, April 6, at the Armenian Cultural and Educational Center (ACEC), focused on the little-known anniversary of the United Nations’ recognition of that bleak chapter.

In August 1985, the UN SubCommission on the Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities, at a Geneva sitting, approved a report that included a paragraph marking the Armenian Genocide. Sassounian told the story to the assembled, unfurling the twists and turns, including his key role, like a mystery. That report is known as the “Whitaker Report.”

In essence, Sassounian urged the Armenian community not to lose hope for either reparations from Turkey nor consider the fate of Karabakh (Artsakh) as fait accompli. Instead, he said members of the community have to pass on the fight for what is right from one generation to another. For example, he cited the change in the status of Turkey, which shrank from an empire to a relatively small country.

Sassounian, a major actor in the adoption of the report, offered a blow-by-blow account of his role making deals with various parties in his capacity as an NGO representative.

Sassounian, the founder and publisher of the California Courier, started by noting the contribution of Polish-born attorney Raphael Lemkin, who came up with the word genocide in the 1940s as a result of studying what had happened to the Armenians.

Harut Sassounian (Aram Arkun photo)

On December 9, 1948, the UN General Assembly adopted the convention of the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide, which went into effect in 1951.

Get the Mirror in your inbox:

“The Genocide Convention defined genocide as the intentional destruction of a national, ethnic, racial or religious group,” he said. “On May 28, 1948, the UN Economic and Social Council … adopted a 368-page report by the UN War Crimes Commission. Eight pages of the report were devoted to the Armenian Massacres. The report quoted the statements issued by France, Great Britain and Russia on May 28, 1915, calling the Armenian Massacres ‘crimes against humanity and civilization,’ warning that all Ottoman leaders would be held personally responsible for the crimes,” he said. They also referred to the Treaty of Sevres which stated that “the Turkish government shall hand over to the Allied Powers the persons responsible for the Armenian massacres.”

In fact, the report said, “The trials held in Istanbul in 1919 of the Ottoman perpetrators of the Armenian massacres were considered a precedent of the Nuremberg Trials.”

This 1948 report, he said, “is unknown because the Turkish government pressured the UN to make it a restricted document.”

In 1969, the UN Economic and Social Council, approved a decision by the SubCommission on the Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities, with 26 human rights experts, to undertake a study on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide.

In 1971, Rwandan Nicodème Ruhashyankiko was appointed the special rapporteur of the SubCommission. He filed several reports. However, in his 1972 preliminary report, there was no reference to the Armenian Genocide. However, in paragraph 30 of the 1973 progress report, he wrote: “Pasing to the modern era, one may note the existence of relatively full documentation dealing with the massacres of Armenians which have been describes as ‘the first face of genocide in the 20th century,’” Sassounian said.

Even this small reference was too much for Turkey, Sassounian added.

“Even though paragraph 30 didn’t even mention Turkey as the perpetrator of the genocide, the Turkish ambassador, by his objection, admitted it was referring to the Turkish genocide,” he said.

Then Turkish Ambassador to the United Nations Osman Olcay, at the Commission on Human Rights in 1974, “strongly objected to the use of the term ‘Armenian Genocide’ and requested it be deleted from the final report.”

Aram Arkun (Kenneth Martin photo)

Sassounian explained that Olcay got support from 11 other countries, including the US, Pakistan, Italy, France, Austria, Iran, Iraq, India, Romania, Ecuador and Nigeria “supported Turkey’s denialist position.”

When the State Department declassified some of its archives in 2006, Sassounian said it was revealed that “Secretary of State Henry Kissinger had sent a cable to the US mission at the UN in 1974 agreeing to cooperate with Turkey on the deletion of reference to the Armenian Genocide in the UN report. Kissinger’s message to Turkey was that the US would support the deletion if other countries agreed to it. The Turkish delegation warmly thanked the US for its support.”

Sassounian detailed the chain of events which led to the inclusion of the Armenian Genocide in the report.

In 1974, an Armenian-American delegation visited several UN missions in New York City, including Tunisia, Austria, Ecuador, Iran, Pakistan, the US, Italy, Iraq and the Netherlands, asking them to support Paragraph 30.

The following year, at the sitting when the report was to be presented, Ruhashyankiko failed to show up after he had deleted Paragraph 30.

In 1978, at the SubCommisssion session, Shavarsh Torigian, representing the NGO World Council of Churches, and also a member of the Armenian National Committee, objected to the deletion, and got support from Argentina, France, Soviet Union, Greece and Syria, but to no avail.

By 1979, Sassounian was living in Geneva and decided to represent the Armenian Cause through various organizations, including the International League of Human Rights, the International Federation of Human Rights and the Indigenous World Association, since there were no Armenian NGOs.

“To make my lobbying task easier, I had asked the ARF Bureau to urge the ANC Chapters in various countries to meet with their foreign ministries to direct their representatives in the UN to support the Genocide report,” he said.

That year, at a speech in the UN, Sassounian objected to Ruhashyankiko deleting the reference to the Armenian Genocide. “After lengthy debates, the commission on human rights suggested that the special rapporteur take into consideration the statements of several countries in favor of including paragraph 30. However, Ruhashyankiko was never heard from again. The genocide report was left hanging without Paragraph 30,” he said.

In 1982, Sassounian contacted Benjamin Whitaker, a member of the SubCommission, and asked him to accept to be the new rapporteur “since as the executive director of the Minority Rights group,…he was very knowledgeable about the Armenian Genocide.”

Sassounian also contacted two other members of the SubCommission who agreed to support Whitaker.

“I did not contact the rest of the SubCommission members so that Turkey would not get wind of my behind-the-scenes orchestration,” Sassounian said.

He then alerted in fall 1983 SubCommission Chair Madame Halima Warzazi of Morocco about the possibility of appointing Whitaker.

“On the opening day of the SubCommission’s 1983 session, when usually no agenda item is discussed, suddenly Madame. Warzazi, who was a close friend of Whitaker, lifted her gavel and said he would be the new rapporteur if there were no objections. Before anyone could react, Madame Warzazi banged her gavel and said since there were no objections, Whitaker was appointed the new rapporteur.”

He added, “The Turkish delegate was in total shock but it was too late to do anything about it.”

In his final report, in paragraph 24, Whitaker included the reference to the Armenian Genocide, with many footnotes.

The paragraph is as follows: “The Nazi aberration has unfortunately not been the only case of genocide in the twentieth century. Among other examples which can be cited as qualifying are the German massacre of Hereros in 1904, the Ottoman massacre of Armenians in 1915–1916, the Ukrainian pogrom of Jews in 1919, the Tutsi massacre of Hutu in Burundi in 1965 and 1972, the Paraguayan massacre of Ache Indians prior to 1974, the Khmer Rouge massacre in Kampuchea between 1975 and 1978, and the contemporary Iranian killings of Baha’is.”

Ara Balikian (Kenneth Martin photo)

In one of the footnotes of his report, Whitaker wrote: “At least one million or well over half of the Armenian population are reliably estimated to have been killed or death marched by independent authorities and eyewitnesses.”

He also quoted the German ambassador from 1915, saying that “the government was pursuing its goal of exterminating the Armenian race in the Ottoman Empire.”

Sassounian said that he took to the floor of the UN SubCommission when the report was released, to speak in its favor.

“I met with most of the 26 members of the SubCommission to convince them to support the report,” he said. “The strangest idea I came up with was when I approached the Syrian member who was going to vote against the report in solidarity with the neighboring Islamic Turkey. I told him to leave the hall when the voting started and not to come back until it was over…. I was able to neutralize his no vote.”

Speaking in support of the report were representatives from Zambia, India, Greece, France, the UK and Argentina.

Whitaker’s report was put to a vote on August 29, 1985, with 14 votes in favor, one opposed and four abstentions.

“The result was astonishing because Turkey had the support of the then 12 NATO members and 40 members of the Islamic Conference. At the end they refrained from supporting Turkey,” he said.

“The Turkish government, having fought for a dozen years to delete the reference to the Armenian genocide, failing to do so, said the report wasn’t that important after all,” Sassounian said.

In 2000, President Kocharyan attended the UN annual meeting in New York as head of state and designated Sassounian as an official member of the Armenian delegation.

In 1988, Sassounian said he went to Geneva to speak about the massacres in Sumgait and Baku, “since as an NGO I had the right to speak.”

“I approached the Soviet delegation at the UN and informed them about my planned speech. I told them that I would not make any harsh remarks about the Soviet Union but focus my remarks on the Azeri murderers. The Soviet representatives were extremely upset and asked me not to bring up the subject at all. I had to tell them that I wasn’t asking for their permission. I was simply giving them a heads-up as a courtesy.” The next day, when my turn came to speak at the UN SubCommission, the minute I pronounced the word Sumgait, the entire Soviet delegation got up and walked out of the UN building.”

In addition to founding the California Courier, Sassounian is the president of the Armenia Artsakh Fund, a non-profit organization that has donated to Armenia and Artsakh over one billion dollars of humanitarian aid, mostly medicines, since 1989 (including its predecessor, the United Armenian Fund).

Before the talk, Hamazkayin Boston’s ArtNova Choir, led by artistic director Arthur Veranian offered several songs, including the hymn Soorp Soorp by Komitas.

In his introductory remarks, Ara Balikan chair of the Armenian General Benevolent Union New England District, paid tribute to the 110th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, saying it “scattered us all across the globe” but that the Armenians had not been silenced. Our resilience is testament to our ability to use our intellect and faith to rebuild and thrive,” he said.

He referred to the ethnic cleansing in Artsakh. “Let us use this occasion not just to talk, but to act. Let us use this occasion to remember that our Artsakh leaders, who remain unlawfully held as hostages, need our voice and actions to get back home as soon as they can.”

Balikian thanked Dr. Ara Nazarian and all the other organizations for hosting this unified program.

Aram Arkun, executive director of the Tekeyan Cultural Association of the United States and Canada, offered the closing remarks. He noted that as Sassounian’s talk made clear, though the road to justice for the Armenians is hard, they have to do something and not lose hope. Like Sassounian, every individual has the possibility of making a difference.

“There is always light somewhere on the horizon,” Arkun said. “It is an uphill battle, but every little bit of the uphill battle contributes to not having the cause forgotten.” This is true both for Artsakh and the events of 110 years ago.

He praised the Boston Armenian community as being strong and united, as shown by this joint commemoration.

Serving as master of ceremonies was Ani Khatchadourian representing the Armenian Revolutionary Federation.

The benediction was offered by the Very Rev. Hrant Tahanian of St. Stephen’s Armenian Apostolic Church.

The event was sponsored by the ARF and several of its affiliated organizations, in addition to the AGBU and the Tekeyan Cultural Association.

 

Get the Mirror-Spectator Weekly in your inbox: